Immigrants Competing for US Citizenship? Controversial TV Pitch Faces Backlash

A proposed reality television show concept titled The American, which would see immigrants competing for US citizenship through a series of challenges, has sparked significant controversy and debate about the ethics of gamifying the naturalisation process. 

The pitch, from producer Rob Worsoff, gained notoriety following a report in the Daily Mail suggesting endorsement from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), a claim the agency has vehemently denied. According to Worsoff, known for his work on shows like Duck Dynasty, the show intends to highlight the personal journeys of immigrants and foster a national conversation about American identity. He assures that unsuccessful contestants would not face any adverse immigration consequences, like deportation.

Despite these assurances, the concept has been met with criticism. Concerns have been raised that the show trivialises the rigorous and legally mandated naturalisation process. This process requires lawful permanent residency, English proficiency, and passing a civics test, as outlined by the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA). Critics argue that bypassing these requirements through a competition diminishes the dignity of immigrants navigating the complex bureaucratic system.

The initial report in the Daily Mail claims that DHS had expressed interest in the show, a claim that the agency has publicly refuted. DHS officials have stated that Secretary Kristi Noem was unaware of the proposal. However, DHS has acknowledged receiving the pitch. A senior DHS official later offered a nuanced perspective, describing the concept as potentially celebrating American ideals and the privilege of citizenship.

The emergence of the American into the public sphere has fueled broader discussions about immigration, national identity, and the influence of entertainment media. Similar shows like America’s Got Talent have previously integrated personal stories of immigrants into their narratives. However, granting citizenship as a prize presents unprecedented legal and ethical questions. Given that DHS receives hundreds of television pitches annually, the future of The American remains uncertain.