Skip to main content

I Come Here to Question Dr. Fred Matiang'i Before I Praise Him

Submitted by mwakilishi on Sat, 12/31/2016 - 20:41

Looks like in Dr. Fred Matiang’i, the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology has found the silver bullet to use in its fight against the ministry’s atrocious record of wholesale sale of exam papers, cheating during said exams, widespread corruption and incompetence not to mention burnt school buildings -- all which boiled over between 2015 and 2016.

At least that appears to be the case following the December 29th release of the 2016 Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education (KCSE) results.

Praise and accolades are coming from all quarters for the surreptitious release of the test results that supposedly “caught the school principals unaware”. Dr. Matiang’i (and Prof. George Magoha of the Kenya National Examination Council – KNEC) are being coronated because the 2016 examinations, unlike those of years past, “appear to have been managed with a higher degree of integrity…..that the results for each candidate reflect their fair performance.”

The desperate clamor to find a silver lining in a feat that is still the proverbial “flash in the pan”, is a sad but unsurprising acknowledgment by a country that has become so accustomed to mediocrity and incompetence that when someone does their job; as outlined in their job description, they are virtually assured of moranhood and well on their way to sainthood -- Kenyanstyle!

Unfortunately, I have seen this movie before and am thus loath to jump onto the “Hongera Bw. Matiang’i” bandwagon with a sample size of n=1. The cautious and utterly skeptical optimist in me will also refuse to lather the commendations onto CS Matiang’i for doing a job he is paid to do, handsomely I might add.

Back in 2013, a majority of Kenyans and members of the Fourth and Fifth Estates breathlessly lauded the in-coming “digital duo” of Uhuru Kenyatta and William Ruto as the incorruptible and youthful leadership the country needed -- given the sordid history of its past (leaders) including Uhuru’s father Jomo, his mentor Arap Moi and godfather Mwai Kibaki.

President Kenyatta was lauded as the “incorruptible scion” of Kenya’s wealthiest family who did not “need to steal money” ostensibly because he already had it by the truckload. His deputy Mr. Ruto was a self-styled “hustler” who pulled himself up by the bootstrap – first by selling chicken. The rest of the cabinet was alternately described as “technocrats” and “experts” who would “discharge (their) respective mandates with integrity, courage and utmost professionalism”.

Kenyans know how that feel-good story has played out – jameni!

The Opus Dei-steeped and frugal current governor of the Central Bank is another public official who came into office amidst a flourish of lofty praises and expectations. His prudent and spare lifestyle including the decision to forego the trappings that came with his office were given intense media coverage and cited as an example of the approach any in-coming head of Kenya’s main bank needed to take. One reporter echoed the sentiments of most Kenyans: That Dr. Paul Njoroge had “refused his turn to eat”.

Fast-forward 16months later and Mr. Njoroge now sits atop an institution whose management has been implicated in financial/banking improprieties that toppled Imperial Bank among other “rogue banks”. And in classic Potomac Two-step fashion, the blame is falling on Dr. Njoroge’s predecessor. Mr. Njuguna Ndung’u, the former Governor is accused of having a “more than cozy relationship” with the managing director (MD) of the failed bank a Mr. Abdulmalek Janmohamed.

The buck indeed stops – elsewhere.

So, what is my point?

Rather than offer nothing but a “healthy dose of skepticism” as I was accused of doing, I was also asked to desist from allowing “history’s defeats (to) ruin today’s victory”. I responded by asking the “All Hail Matiang’i” crowd to stop overlooking and/or minimizing the lessons of recent past – on matters of corruption and incompetence – especially in instances where lots of money is involved as is the case with the rot pervading Dr. Matiang’i’s ministry.

What Kenyans have repeatedly seen over the last three years are deified leaders, who after the single accomplishment that garnered them the spotlight, almost immediately invariably disappoint. They either turn out to be incompetent, personally corrupt, indebted to the shadowy corrupt “cartels” which often include family members or as having completely underestimated the Sisyphean task they were brought in to clean.

Given the foregoing, I’d (a) temper praising Dr. Matiang'i -- for doing a job he's being paid to do, (b) have the good doctor explain to an impressed nation (including his boss and deputy) how he cleaned out King Augeas' stables so the formula can be duplicated elsewhere, and most importantly, (c) preserve the concoction Dr. Matiang’i and Prof. Magoha used to stop the cheating, selling of exam papers and burning of schools in 2016 so it can be duplicated in 2017 and beyond.

By Washington Osiro |


As long as the culprits are still at large,and roaming around free,they will converge again and go back to their corrupt ways. They are so used to "easy money",and will just lay low,and plot better ways to corrupt the department of education. I would breath easy,and part Matiang'i on the back if these cooks are in prison.

Peterson Githungo

Wed, 01/04/2017 - 13:47

What was your question again for Dr. Matiangi? You piss on his achievements that are noticeable to everybody and then you want the public servant to teach others the secret behind his success? Failure is not always a collorary of public praise. Does your disappointment with others earn him that level of cynicism from you? Your reference to his pay as the reason we shouldn't recognize his achievement is petty. True, he is in the public service, being paid and should therefore deliver but those are words to come out of his mouth in self-deprecation, not from a critic especially after the CS has earned his keep. His breath of freshness to a rotten system must be recognized unless you are a ne'er-do-well who has never known the price associated with excellent public service. Or is because Matiangi epitomizes a system of government that is finally waking up from a slumber, and you'd rather they slept on for the political advantage to be had by your preferred candidate? What is "sad" about praising a man cleaning out a an education system? Were we not taught in our civics classes that acknowledgement of good in society is a moral necessity where such is earned? One would hope that by now you have watched his latest interview on TV. Bw. Osiro, your contrarian view seems to be much-ado-about-nothing.

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.